Is starting J.J. McCarthy the right choice? BBV staff weighs in

Big Blue View writers debated New York Giants head coach John Harbaugh's decision to name J.J. McCarthy the starting quarterback over Jameis Winston. McCarthy will make his first start for the team on Sunday against the Houston Texans after replacing Winston during a loss to the New Orleans Saints. The Giants previously acquired McCarthy in a trade for a fifth-round draft pick.

Several writers, including Chris Pflum, Jeremy Brener, and Ed Valentine, argued the change provides greater mobility and offensive upside following Jaxson Dart's season-ending injury. However, Tony Del Genio expressed concern that benching Winston after one poor game could damage locker room trust, while David Hartman warned of a difficult matchup against Houston's pass rush.