Phillies Report Card: Otto Kemp

Anthony Esbensen evaluates Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Otto Kemp's 2026 season, giving him a "D-" grade following a disappointing campaign. Initially planned as a platoon partner with Brandon Marsh against left-handed pitching, Kemp struggled significantly at the plate and defensively, ultimately striking out against Atlanta Braves pitcher Chris Sale to end Philadelphia's season in Game 3 of the National League Wild Card series.

Esbensen details how Kemp made the Opening Day roster but was quickly optioned after going 2-for-20 with nine strikeouts. After another brief, hitless call-up, Kemp spent four months away from the majors before injuries led to a postseason roster spot, where his struggles ultimately concluded the Phillies' year.