My All-MLB Ballot

Brew Crew Ball writer Paul Dietrich presents his personal selections for the 2026 All-MLB team following the league's official ballot release. Dietrich outlines his top choices across each position, highlighting standout offensive and defensive performers from across Major League Baseball over the course of the campaign.

Dietrich's position player selections feature Pete Crow-Armstrong, Yordan Alvarez, Bobby Witt Jr., Pete Alonso, Gabriel Moreno, Brice Turang, Junior Caminero, Randy Arozarena, and Fernando Tatis Jr. The writer also names Jacob Misiorowski and Cam Schlittler among his preferred starting pitchers.