Do the Jets have an Isaiah Williams problem?

Writer MacGregor Wells argues that New York Jets punt returner Isaiah Williams is experiencing a concerning slump in 2026 following a stellar 2025 campaign. After averaging 14.1 yards per punt return with two touchdowns last year, Williams struggled heavily in a Week 2 game against the Green Bay Packers, fumbling twice in the first quarter.

Wells highlights statistical declines across multiple areas, noting Williams's return average dropped to 6.2 yards and he has not returned a punt since the fumbles. The writer suggests that if Williams does not rebound quickly, recently promoted practice squad player Jamaal Pritchett could potentially replace him.