Free extension for sports fans
Advertisement
Advertisement

In the lab: Hall of Fame index second base part two

Last time, we took a look at the rank and file Hall of Famers at the second base position. We do this to provide a baseline for what we are looking for in current candidates. Obviously, there are a handful…

Published: Wednesday, 28 October 2026 at 12:14 PM
In the lab: Hall of Fame index second base part two
Key Things to Know
  • Scott Barzilla argues Jose Altuve likely already has the credentials for the Hall of Fame based on index metrics.
  • Altuve holds a 219.6 index score, nearing the Hall of Fame median of 220 to 230 for second basemen.
  • Contemporaries Marcus Semien and Ketel Marte trail with index scores of 174.3 and 145.1, respectively.
The Story in 60 Seconds

Writer Scott Barzilla evaluates Jose Altuve's Cooperstown credentials using his sabermetric Hall of Fame index, comparing the Houston Astros second baseman to contemporaries Marcus Semien and Ketel Marte. Based purely on the index score of 219.6, Barzilla argues that Altuve likely already has the necessary credentials to enter the Hall of Fame if he were to retire immediately.

The analysis notes that the median index for Hall of Fame second basemen sits between 220 and 230. Barzilla highlights that while Semien and Marte still require additional production to reach Cooperstown standards, Altuve's candidacy remains strong despite complications from the sign-stealing scandal and potential rate stat declines as he continues to play through his contract.

Advertisement

Never Miss a Sports Update

Get the latest sports news and top stories from MySportsTab delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam. Just the latest sports news and updates.