Stay or Go: What should the Phillies do with Bryce Harper?

Phillies Nation writers unanimously argue that the Philadelphia Phillies should keep Bryce Harper this offseason rather than attempt to trade him. While the organization faces offseason questions following another early postseason exit, writer Destiny Lugardo notes that Harper holds a full no-trade clause and remains committed to Philadelphia heading into year nine of his 13-year contract.

The staff highlights Harper's durable 2026 campaign, where he played in all 162 games and recorded a team-leading 131 OPS+ alongside 107 walks. Editorial director Ty Daubert and staff writers Bailey Digh and Nathan Ackerman argue that trading the team's best offensive producer would severely weaken an already struggling lineup ahead of the 2027 season.