Bills grades, Josh Allen vs. Lamar Jackson and life under Joe Brady: The Satchel

The Athletic evaluates the Buffalo Bills' 5-1 start under new head coach Joe Brady, grading the offense an A and the defense a D-minus. While Josh Allen's MVP-caliber play and strong special teams have carried Buffalo to the top of the conference power rankings, defensive coordinator Jim Leonhard's unit has struggled severely, surrendering at least 29 points in five of six games.

The piece also addresses the ongoing debate between Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson, arguing Allen's durability and consistency give him a clear edge over Baltimore's frequently injured quarterback. Additionally, the analysis highlights Brady's relaxed, approachable locker-room culture compared to former coach Sean McDermott, while noting defensive scheme transitions and linebacker struggles remain pressing concerns.