Former Twin Tyler Duffey proposes Josh Naylor trade idea that Minnesota should avoid

It's an intriguing idea, but the numbers suggest it would be a mistake.

By Jackson Kruse · Puckett's Pond

Published: Sunday, 18 October 2026 at 10:00 PM

Key Things to Know

Writer Jackson Kruse argues the Twins should avoid trading for Mariners first baseman Josh Naylor despite Tyler Duffey's suggestion.
Tyler Duffey proposed acquiring Naylor via trade to bring energy, power, and clubhouse presence to Minnesota.
Naylor is owed $83.9 million under a long-term contract running through the 2030 MLB season.

The Story in 60 Seconds

Former Minnesota Twins reliever Tyler Duffey suggested on a podcast that Minnesota should explore a trade for Seattle Mariners first baseman Josh Naylor. Writing for Puckett's Pond, Jackson Kruse argues that the Twins should avoid pursuing Naylor due to his significant contract and declining production during his recent campaign in Seattle.

Naylor is owed nearly $84 million through 2030 and struggled with injuries and a dip in performance before undergoing postseason wrist surgery. Kruse contends Minnesota should not consider a trade unless the Mariners are willing to absorb a substantial portion of his remaining salary.

Read the full article on Puckett's Pond

Former Twin Tyler Duffey proposes Josh Naylor trade idea that Minnesota should avoid

More Minnesota Twins News

Never Miss a Sports Update