Free extension for sports fans

THE RIVALRY CONTINUES

by Holly Horning Last week, I blogged about how it often takes years before we truly know how well an expensive player signing will be. Sometimes it bombs immediately, sometimes it takes 2-3 years. Sometimes longer. And then sometimes it…

Published: Wednesday, 30 September 2026 at 12:31 AM
THE RIVALRY CONTINUES
Key Things to Know
  • Holly Horning argues that the Tigers dodged a bullet by letting Max Scherzer leave after 2014.
  • The column criticizes Scherzer for allegedly attempting to one-up Justin Verlander during season-ending games.
  • The writer claims Scherzer pushed to start on short rest for Toronto to chase Verlander's strikeout tally.
The Story in 60 Seconds

Holly Horning of Totally Tigers argues that the Detroit Tigers avoided long-term organizational trouble by not re-signing Max Scherzer after the 2014 season. Reflecting on recent season-ending starts by both Scherzer and Justin Verlander, the column characterizes the ongoing rivalry between the former teammates as contrasting Verlander's loyalty with what the writer views as Scherzer's self-centered behavior.

Horning alleges that Scherzer's recent Sunday appearance for the Toronto Blue Jays on short rest was an orchestrated attempt to overshadow Verlander's emotional farewell weekend and surpass his career strikeout total. The writer contends that Scherzer's antics and interactions with managers demonstrate performative actions that would have created negative friction in Detroit.

Never Miss a Sports Update

Get the latest sports news and top stories from MySportsTab delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam. Just the latest sports news and updates.