James Tarkowski has given Everton a defensive dilemma – and Jake O’Brien has work to do

Harry Diamond argues that James Tarkowski's resurgence alongside Jarrad Branthwaite has created a selection dilemma for Everton manager David Moyes, leaving Jake O'Brien facing an uphill battle for playing time. After facing criticism late last season, Tarkowski has rebounded to lead the Premier League with an 81.36% duel success rate across seven games, helping Everton secure five clean sheets in all competitions.

Diamond writes that O'Brien, who has played only 17 league minutes this season, must show significant improvement in aerial duels and passing to displace the veteran captain. While the writer notes succession planning remains necessary given Tarkowski turns 34 soon, Diamond concludes that Tarkowski's strong form prevents O'Brien from walking into the starting lineup by default.