Home » Football » Scottish Premiership » Celtic F.C.

Martin O’Neill’s Celtic Verdict Beggars Belief – Is His Reputation Protecting Him?

Martin O’Neill Celtic criticism grows after his upbeat Benfica verdict. Are Celtic’s poor results finally putting the manager under scrutiny?

By Phillip Cooney · ReadCeltic

Published: Friday, 16 October 2026 at 5:03 PM

Key Things to Know

Phillip Cooney argues Martin O'Neill's reputation should not shield him from accountability following Celtic's 4-1 loss to Benfica.
Celtic suffered a 4-1 defeat against Benfica in the Europa League after falling behind by three goals at halftime.
O'Neill claimed to Celtic TV that his side was "brilliant" during their improved second-half display.

The Story in 60 Seconds

Writer Phillip Cooney criticizes Celtic manager Martin O'Neill for calling his team "brilliant" in the second half of a 4-1 Europa League defeat to Benfica. Cooney argues that O'Neill's legendary status should not shield him from scrutiny after Celtic fell three goals behind prior to halftime.

Cooney highlights growing concerns over Celtic's form, noting the club has conceded 12 goals in three European games and suffered two defeats to Rangers. While substitutes Haissem Hassan and Callum Osmand improved the attack, Cooney asserts O'Neill must take responsibility for poor initial tactical setups.

Read the full article on ReadCeltic

Martin O’Neill’s Celtic Verdict Beggars Belief – Is His Reputation Protecting Him?

More Celtic News

Never Miss a Sports Update