Free extension for sports fans

Messiahs to mugs: Is Scottish football’s boom or bust culture holding us back?

As players and managers are written off one week only to be lauded the next, Graeme McGarry asks if Scottish football's instant reaction culture is holding us back.

Published: Wednesday, 23 September 2026 at 5:00 AM
Messiahs to mugs: Is Scottish football’s boom or bust culture holding us back?
Key Things to Know
  • Scottish football discourse is increasingly driven by extreme week-to-week reactions fueled by social media.
  • Managerial pressure has quickly shifted from Rangers manager Derek McInnes to Celtic manager Martin O'Neill.
  • Motherwell manager Alfred Johansson is facing criticism after enduring three consecutive losses.
The Story in 60 Seconds

Graeme McGarry examines the rapid shifts in managerial perceptions across Scottish football, driven by modern 24/7 media and social media reactions. The column notes that while Rangers manager Derek McInnes recently faced heavy pressure, the focus has swiftly shifted to Celtic manager Martin O'Neill following recent results.

The volatile culture extends beyond the traditional Glasgow rivals to clubs across the league. Motherwell manager Alfred Johansson faces criticism following three consecutive losses, while St Mirren manager Craig McLeish also received fan frustration after a weekend defeat to Dundee United.

Never Miss a Sports Update

Get the latest sports news and top stories from MySportsTab delivered straight to your inbox.

No spam. Just the latest sports news and updates.