The Yankees cannot replace Paul Blackburn with just a closer

Alexander Wilson of Empire Sports Media argues that the New York Yankees cannot address their bullpen needs solely with a closer, stressing the importance of addressing Paul Blackburn's free agency. Blackburn, who previously signed a one-year, $2 million deal, provided crucial length by pitching 85 innings across 62 appearances in the 2026 regular season, including 32 multi-inning outings.

Wilson suggests the Yankees should consider a short-term offer to retain Blackburn alongside pursuing closer options like David Bednar. However, the writer notes New York must balance his multi-inning utility against modest strikeout rates and potential regression, or rely on pitching coach Matt Blake to develop a cheaper alternative.