Grading the 2026 Phillies bullpen: Can it be salvaged?

That Balls Outta Here's Ethan Williams graded the Philadelphia Phillies' 2026 bullpen following a disappointing Wild Card Series exit. Williams argues that while the relief corps suffered from severe injuries and overall ineffectiveness, standout performances from top relievers offered a few bright spots. Closer Jhoan Duran earned the highest grade (A+) after recording 33 saves with a 1.82 ERA, while rookie Alex McFarlane (A) and veteran Tim Mayza (A-) also received high marks.

In contrast, Williams assigned failing "F" grades to Tanner Banks, Jose Alvarado, and trade acquisition Brooks Raley, who posted a 7.94 ERA with Philadelphia. High-priced addition Brad Keller received a "D" after an injury-shortened season requiring Tommy John surgery, while Orion Kerkering (D+) struggled down the stretch and was left off the postseason roster.