Jose Altuve’s future is the most delicate question of the Astros’ offseason

Jose Altuve's future as the franchise icon is an uncomfortable Astros question.

By Scott Barzilla · Climbing Tal's Hill

Published: Friday, 16 October 2026 at 2:12 PM

Key Things to Know

Scott Barzilla argues the Astros should transition franchise icon Jose Altuve into a full-time designated hitter role.
Altuve is owed $33 million next season, with salaries dropping to $13 million annually in 2028 and 2029.
Defensive evaluation systems show Altuve has steadily declined into a significant defensive liability at second base.

The Story in 60 Seconds

Scott Barzilla of Climbing Tal's Hill argues that the Houston Astros must address Jose Altuve's declining defensive metrics and transition him to full-time designated hitter. Altuve has three years remaining on his contract, earning $33 million next season before his salary decreases to $13 million annually in 2028 and 2029.

Barzilla highlights that defensive metrics like DRS, OAA, and FRV have severely penalized Altuve's defense in recent seasons. Moving Altuve to DH presents complications, including managing Yordan Alvarez's outfield workload and finding an everyday replacement at second base among internal options like Brice Matthews, Cavan Biggio, or Nick Allen.

Read the full article on Climbing Tal's Hill

Jose Altuve’s future is the most delicate question of the Astros’ offseason

More Houston Astros News

Never Miss a Sports Update